THE Masked Singer revealed Queer Eye's Bobby Berk as the Caterpillar in tonight’s shocking semi-finals elimination. 

Before the Netflix star took off his mask, judge Jenny McCarthy was slammed for making the “embarrassing” prediction that the contestant was Jake Gyllenhaal - which ended up being far off.

FoxThe Masked Singer eliminated Bobby Berk as the Caterpillar in tonight’s shocking semi-finals '/caption '

FoxJenny McCarthy was so ...confident' in her guess she used her one & only Take It Off buzzer '/caption '

The Mega AgencyThe Masked Singer judge was ...confident' Jake Gyllenhaal sang on the show '/caption '

On tonight’s Group B semi-finals, the fuzzy little bug belted out the Garth Brooks classic, Friends In Low Places. 

This season for the first time ever, the show debuted the Take It Off Buzzer - which could only be used once for the whole season. 

In order to press the buzzer, the judge had to be 100% certain they know who the person under the mask is and if the panelist is right, the singer had to take their mask off immediately on stage. 

If the judge was correct in their prediction, the contestant would be sent home on the spot. 

While Jenny, 49, was “completely confident” the performer was Jake, 40, and used her ONE chance at the buzzer, the guess ended up being far off. 

                                        Most read in The US Sun

            DEATH PENALTY PLEA          

            Death row inmate's sister denied meeting governor ahead of execution            

            IN DESPERATE NEED           

            ‘Secret stimulus check’ sent out as calls grow for more mortgage relief         

            STORE SHOOTING          

            Rapper, 36, shot and killed as fans pay tribute to 'King of Memphis' star           

            MARKED CARD         

            Palace 'will dread Meghan's surprise interview with Ellen as she's RUTHLESS'            

            CREEPY CRAWLERS         

            Plague of 50million CANNIBAL CRABS swarm roads on way to breeding ground            

            CHECK IT OUT            

            Surprise stimulus checks of $2,000 & $1,000 are being sent out          

Fans slammed her for the wrong assumption, with one writing: ...What are these judges smoking???

...No offense to the show but current trendy superstars are not under a mask!!! Sia? Garth Brooke, Jake, etc? NO!...

Another tweeted: ...That was clearly not Jake Gyllenhaal. They must be told to give a bad answer when using that buzzer....

One more agreed, saying: ...Jenny is insane! That was definitely not Jake Gyllenhaal!!! Embarrassing guess and a waste of the buzzer....

Brokeback Mountain actor Jake has come under fire this week following the re-release of his ex, Taylor Swift...s, 2012 heartbreak album, Red.

The songwriter took aim at a former lover of hers with scathing lyrics throughout the record - which many people insist are about her 2011 romance with Jake.

Most famously, she fired off a furious insult in the highly-anticipated 10 minute version of what is widely considered her magnum opus, All Too Well (Taylor's Version.)


...And I was never good at telling jokes but the punch line goes... I'll get older but your lovers stay my age,... she sings in the fan-favorite track of the actor's habit of dating younger women.

Later in the episode, it was revealed that the Caterpillar would be one of two contestants sent home in a shocking double elimination ahead of next week’s finale. 

Attempting to make her second stab at a guess more accurate, Jenny switched to insisting the Caterpillar was Wedding Crashers star Owen Wilson. 

Fellow panelist Ken Jeong predicted Schitt’s Creek creator and star Dan Levy while Nicole Scherzinger was adamant he was Tyler Hubbard from country duo Florida Georgia Line.

Robin Thicke said it was Backstreet Boy member AJ McClean while judge Cheryl Hines believed it was Big Bang Theory actor Jim Parsons 

However, when host Nick Cannon saw who was under the mask, he exclaimed the contestant “fooled them all,” referring to the judges. 

“We can add the title of ‘singer’ to your long list of accomplishments,” Nick gushed. 

Jenny added to the compliments, saying: “I can’t believe this, your voice is incredible!” 

        Winners of the Masked Singer

                <img src="" width="620" height="413" />             

                The Masked Singer is a reality series that airs on Fox. Celebrities dress in costume and perform in front of a panel of judges. The singers give the audience clues on who they are. The show premiered in 2019.                

Season one winner: T-Pain who dressed as the Peacock Season two winner: Wayne Brady who dressed as the Fox Season three winner: Kandi Burruss who dressed as the Night Angel Season four winner: LeAnn Rimes who dressesd as the Sun Season five winner: Nick Lachey who dressed as the Piglet

As his last day as the Caterpillar, Bobby, 40, said on stage to the judges: “Thank you guys for going out in the world and entertaining people. 

“More than ever, we need amazing people like you that make us smile. No many how stupid some of the things you guys say are.”

Also on tonight’s Masked Singer, The Mallard was voted off in the double elimination and was revealed to be Duck Dynasty...s Willie Roberston. 

As their final guesses, Nicole picked Dog The Bounty Hunter while Ken said it was Billy Ray Cyrus. 

Robin predicted Alan Jackson while Jenny insisted it was Jason Aldean and guest host Cheryl said George Foreman. 

Willie, 49, said he thought the panel's picks were ...hilarious... as most of those guesses were his friends - who he knows will ...lose it... when they watch the episode.

Duck Dynasty star Willie Robertson was revealed to be The Mallard

FoxThe Mallard was also eliminated on tonight's shocking semi-finals episode '/caption '

FoxJenny McCarthy used the Take It Off buzzer to incorrectly guess Caterpillar as Jake Gyllenhaal '/caption '

Getty Images - GettyTaylor Swift re-released her album, Red, widely believed to be about her ex Jake '/caption '

        We pay for your stories!

                Do you have a story for The US Sun team?                

Email us at or call 212 416 4552. Like us on Facebook at and follow us from our main Twitter account at @TheSunUS